Return to Our Submarine History

WWII   Big mouthed politician may have reulted in the
sinking of as many as 10 US Submarines

FROM Rontini's SUBMARINE BBS  14 MAY 2000

THE ORIGINAL BBS POSTING from Bud Turner Ex-MT2(SS) SSBN634 Gold Plank Owner:

In Gene Fluckey's book, "Thunder Below," on page 275 he states: "Admiral Lockwood was adamant that submarine operations not be publicized for at least 60 days afterward. For instance, known losses of our subs were not listed as 'overdue and presumed lost' until two months later. Admiral Nimitz understood this. As one of our earliest submariners, he would never forget the secret briefing at Pearl that went awry and cost us 10 subs.

A politician had informed the press that the Japanese were not setting their depth charges deep enough to sink more of our submarines. A war crime!"


AN ANSWER:
Clay Blair in "Silent Victory", Vol.1 pg 397 credits Congressman Andrew Jackson May, a member of the House Military Affairs Committee with the breach of security.

Blair does not name any specific newspaper but said the wire services sent out the story and many newspapers, including one in Honolulu published it. After the war Lockwood said that the story cost us 10 submarines and 800 officers and men.

Posted by Tom parks WWII US Submarine veteran.


Related links:
http://research.info.com/searchw?qkw=Andrew+J.+May
MAY, Andrew Jackson (1875-1959) Biographical Information
Sourced from POLITICALGRAVEYARD.COM
The Congressman Credited with Sinking up to Ten Submarines